|Portrayed by:||Michelle Borth|
Dean meets her in his apartment in the alternative world created by the Djinn. She is dating him and living with Dean. She also knows all Dean's favorite foods and beer. She is Dean's ideal girlfriend. When Dean goes to celebrate his mother's birthday, Carmen tags along. Although, when Dean figures out this is all a dream she tries to convince him to stay.
In the real world, she is a model for Dean's favorite beer. So Carmen is not real, but the model on the beer ad is.