Lily Shoemaker is the young daughter of Steven Shoemaker.
Lily Shoemaker is a 12-year-old girl living with her older sister Donna Shoemaker and her father. One night she was hosting a sleepover with her friends, and they were playing the game Truth or Dare. She was dared to go into the bathroom and say Bloody Mary in the mirror three times. She does, but nothing happens to her. However, when her father comes down to calm down the noise, he goes back upstairs and figure appears in all the mirrors he passes. He goes into the bathroom to take his pills, and he is killed by Bloody Mary.