Alerted to strange happenings in Clayton Falls, Colorado, Bobby sends Sam and Dean to check it out. A speeding car with no driver, a homeless man pursued by a massive Gila monster, a little boy attacked by uprooted trees-it all sounds like the stuff of nightmares. The brothers fight to survive a series of terrifying nighttimes, realizing that sometimes the nightmares don't go away - even when you're awake...
- Bobby Singer
- Gavin Shelburn
- Alden Webb
- Olga Kucharski
- Teodor Kucharski
- Jozef Wieczorek
- Clive Gillmer
- Ragnar Bartch
- Kurt Machalek
- Richard Jeffries
- Michael Quinn
- Trevor Deetz
- Linda Deetz
- Soulless Sam (nightmares and nightmare manifestation)
- Lisa Braeden (nightmare only)
- Ben Braeden (nightmare only)
Featured Supernatural BeingsEdit
- Night Hag (Olga's Night Hag)
- Zombies (nightmare manifestations)
- Vengeful Spirit (Clive Gillmer)
- Eve (mentioned only)
- Khan worm (referenced only)
- Tulpa (mentioned only)
- Arachne (mentioned only)
- Ghoul (nightmare only)
- Seraph (Castiel; mentioned only)
- Archangels (Michael, Lucifer; mentioned only)
- Takes place between Frontierland and Mommy Dearest.
- Bobby is stated to be looking for Eve with no luck after getting the phoenix ash.
- Rufus Turner's death in ...And Then There Were None as well as the khan worm are mentioned.
- Dean is shown to be afraid of a vengeful spirit taking control of the Impala again. This is a reference to Rose Brown's actions in Mannequin 3: The Reckoning.
- Sam remembers the situation with the Arachne and his soulless self from Unforgiven.
- After seeing the tornado that the night hag is causing, Dean makes a reference to the movie Twister. Specifically, Dean jokes that at least there's no flying cows involved, a reference to the scene in Twister when the storm chasers encounter a cow being sent flying across the road twice by a tornado.