- "They say this gun can kill anything."
- —John Winchester
The gun used in the series is actually a replica Colt ball and cap gun modified to fire metallic cartridges. On the barrel of the gun is inscribed the Latin phrase "non timebo mala", meaning "I fear no evil".
On the handle is a carving of a pentagram, with much of the finish removed to give it an aged appearance. It originally came with 13 bullets - eight were used before the Winchesters obtained it, and they used the other five. It then no longer worked. However, the demon Ruby and Bobby Singer, managed to make more bullets for it.
The legend of The Colt, as told by John Winchester, is as follows:
- "Back in 1835, when Halley's Comet was overhead, the same night those men died at the Alamo, they say Samuel Colt made a gun...a special gun. He made it for a hunter -- a man like us, only on horseback. The story goes he made 13 bullets. This hunter used the gun a half dozen times before he disappeared, the gun along with him. Somehow, Daniel got his hands on it. They say -- they say this gun can kill anything."
- —John Winchester
When John Winchester became aware of the power that the weapon had, he began to search for it so that he could use it to kill the demon that killed his wife - Azazel. He and his sons finally obtained it after a vampire killed the owner, Daniel Elkins, and the Winchesters attacked the vampire's nest to get it back. However, John gives it to Azazel in return for Dean's life being spared after an almost-fatal car crash, and at the end of the second season, Azazel uses it as a key to open a gateway to Hell that Samuel Colt had sealed. Dean uses the last original bullet to kill him.
Towards the end of the third season, the gun was stolen from them by Bela Talbot in order for her to get out of her contract with a Crossroad Demon. She told the Winchesters that she gave it to Lilith, but in fact she instead gave it to a demon named Crowley, who hid it. It is then featured in two time-travel episodes, before Crowley returns it to the Winchesters so that they can kill Lucifer. It is seen once more when the Winchesters travel to 1861. Dean drops the Colt just before being transported back to the present day, where it is retrieved by the saloon owner Elkins, a possible ancestor of Daniel Elkins, who possessed the weapon at the beginning of the series.
As of present days, the whereabouts of The Colt is unknown, presumably destroyed or sealed away by Lucifer.
The Colt's original thirteen bullets could kill almost anything; there were only five things in all of creation (including Lucifer) that couldn't be killed by the revolver.
After using all the bullets, Ruby somehow helped Bobby make other bullets that can kill supernatural monsters. The Colt has a second function: the barrel of it acted as a key to unlock a Devil's Gate, as seen in the episode All Hell Breaks Loose - Part 2.
The following denotes the known uses of the Colt with the original "Samuel Colt" bullets shown in the color grey:
|Image||Number||Gun handler||Reason||Result of shot||Episode|
|Not seen in the series.||# 1-5||Original hunter for whom the Colt was made (possibly Samuel Colt himself)||Unknown||Unknown||N/A|
|# 6-7||Samuel Colt||To kill two demons||Both demons killed||Frontierland|
|# 8||Dean Winchester||To kill the Phoenix, Elias Finch||Kill||Frontierland|
|# 9||John Winchester||To kill the vampire Luther||Kill||Dead Man's Blood|
|#10||Sam Winchester||To kill the demon, Azazel |
|#11||Dean Winchester||To kill a demon, Tom||Kill||Devil's Trap|
|#12||Sam Winchester||To wound Azazel who was possessing John Winchester||Wounded John in the leg;|
Azazel depossessed John
|#13||Dean Winchester||To kill the demon, Azazel||Kill||All Hell Breaks Loose Part 2|
|#14||Bobby Singer||To kill the demon Father Gil||Missed||Sin City|
|#15 & 16||Sam Winchester||To kill the demon Father Gil and Casey.||Kill||Sin City|
|#17||Sam Winchester||To kill a Crossroad demon||Kill||Bedtime Stories|
|#18||Dean Winchester||To kill a vampire.||Kill||Fresh Blood|
|#19||Dean Winchester||To kill the demon Ruby||Missed; shot in the air||Malleus Maleficarum|
|#20||Sam Winchester||To kill the demon Astaroth.||Astaroth stopped the bullet using telekinesis||Malleus Maleficarum|
|#21-22||Crowley||To kill two Demons||Hit, both Demons killed||Abandon All Hope|
|#23||Dean Winchester||To kill a hellhound||Hit, kill unconfirmed but probable||Abandon All Hope|
|#24||Dean Winchester||To kill Lucifer||Shot in the head, his immunity to the Colt prevents death. Though his pain was evident.||Abandon All Hope|
- The props department of the show has a rubber version to be used in fight scenes for pistol whipping.
- Lucifer mentioned that there are only 5 things in creation the Colt cannot kill in Abandon All Hope....
- Despite being in the possession of Hell during the ushering of the Apocalypse, the Colt (along with Death's Scythe) was never used by demons offensively against angels.
- The Colt has appeared at least once in every season, except Season Seven, Season Eight and Season Nine.
- As Eric Kripke mentioned he was inspired by Hellblazer, it is possible that the Colt was based on the Ace of Winchesters, a magical rifle from the Old West that John Constantine of the Hellblazer series uses to instantly kill demons. It is interesting to note that the name of the rifle also shares the surname of Sam and Dean.
- The five created beings that cannot be killed by the Colt include Lucifer, so it presumed that beings as strong or stronger than him are also immune. This presumably includes the archangels, the horsmen, Eve, and the Leviathans.