Tommy was with his girlfriend Shelly when he begins to hear the Wendigo again after all these years. He arms himself with a blow torch, but falls under a spell that causes him to bleed from the ears and eyes until Tommy's head explodes.
Crowley later contacts the Winchesters and directs them to an article on Tommy's death. Crowley reveals that he is now targeting everyone that the Winchesters have ever saved and will kill them until the Winchesters stop the Trials of God and give him the Demon Tablet.
- Tommy was the first person Sam and Dean have been seen saving in the series.