In Oak Park, Illinois, Walter Rosen is putting out his garbage when the street lights flicker and dark clouds roil From the sky a stream of black substance overtakes Walter. He has been possessed by the demon Envy.
In Nebraska, he is caught on video causing a woman to kill another over a pair of shoes. Isaac and Tamara try and catch him at a bar, but other demons overpower them and Isaac is killed. Sam, Dean, and Bobby save Tamara and trap Walter in the trunk under a devil's trap.
They interrogate Envy who is possessing Walter. He taunts that humans possess all the vices they represent, and warns that the other demons will track them down. He taunts Dean about his lust and gluttony, and Tamara about her wrath. Tamara then exorcises Envy, and Walter dies in the process.